JournalArta
Saturday, November 21, 2026 · JakartaS&P 6,910.39 ▼3.70%USD/IDR 18,158 ▼0.42%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Judge Rules Brooke Rollins’ Christian Emails Unconstitutional

By Elena Vance
WIB2 min read
Judge Rules Brooke Rollins' Christian Emails Unconstitutional
Judge Rules Brooke Rollins’ Christian Emails Unconstitutional

A federal judge ruled that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins broke the Constitution by sending Christian messages to the agency's 100,000 employees from her official email account, and ordered her to stop.

US District Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco issued the ruling Thursday and granted a preliminary injunction on the workers' constitutional claim, finding that Rollins' Christmas and Easter messages pressured staff who do not share her faith.

What the judge found

Thompson pointed to three things: Rollins' position of authority, her use of a government email account, and wording that suggested Christianity is the shared religion of the Department of Agriculture's workforce.

Advertisement

The messages went out on holidays including Independence Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter. Rollins did not send notes marking holidays from other religions.

"The secretary must recognize certain boundaries when communicating religious messages," Thompson wrote in the 21-page ruling.

The Easter email, sent April 5, compared staff to the first disciples and urged them to be "alive with hope, full of Paschal joy." Her Christmas message described Jesus as the savior who came to free humanity from sin, and her Easter greeting declared: "He is Risen indeed!"

Thompson said Rollins appeared "to exploit her position of authority." The judge found the emails violated the First Amendment's establishment clause, which bars the government from favoring one religion.

Advertisement

What Rollins must do now

The injunction sets limits on how the secretary communicates with her staff. Rollins must stop if a colleague asks her to, and she cannot create a hostile work environment through repeated, unwanted religious messages.

The case covered emails sent to every USDA employee, making the ruling apply across the department rather than to a single office.

The administration's response

A USDA spokesperson called the decision "a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary." The agency said it is considering its options.

That response signals the fight may continue. An appeal would send the dispute to a higher federal court, where the injunction could be upheld, narrowed or overturned. The ruling stands while any appeal proceeds unless a court pauses it.

Advertisement

Why it matters beyond the USDA

The decision tests how far a senior official can go in mixing personal faith with government business. Thompson's reasoning rests on the power gap between a Cabinet secretary and the career staff who report to her.

That principle could reach other agencies where political appointees communicate directly with large workforces through official channels. The case also turns on a simple test the judge set out: a subordinate's request to stop carries weight.

For the roughly 100,000 people who work at the Agriculture Department, the practical change is immediate. Their inboxes are now subject to a court order.

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Stock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at MiddayStock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at Midday
  2. 2Joachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 SignalJoachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 Signal
  3. 3Stock Market Today: Nasdaq, S&P 500 Futures Slide as AI Selloff DeepensStock Market Today: Nasdaq, S&P 500 Futures Slide as AI Selloff Deepens
  4. 4Kenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in DoubtKenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in Doubt
  5. 5Pat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell JohnsonPat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell Johnson
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Carlton Boss Chris Davies Says Blues List Still Needs WorkSport · FootballCarlton Boss Chris Davies Says Blues List Still Needs WorkNov 21
  2. Nasdaq Drops 5.28% as Tech Stocks Tumble and Treasury Yields FallMarkets · StocksNasdaq Drops 5.28% as Tech Stocks Tumble and Treasury Yields FallNov 21
  3. Anthropic’s Amodei Siblings Keep Firm Weird After IPOMarkets · StocksAnthropic’s Amodei Siblings Keep Firm Weird After IPONov 21
  4. GTA 6 Puts Parents on Alert Over Mature ContentTechnology · GamingGTA 6 Puts Parents on Alert Over Mature ContentNov 21
  5. Advertisement
  6. Bumblebees Solve New Problems and Learn From Each OtherTechnologyBumblebees Solve New Problems and Learn From Each OtherNov 21
  7. Five Great Reads Puts Russell Brand Trial Beside Another CaseLifestyle · EntertainmentFive Great Reads Puts Russell Brand Trial Beside Another CaseNov 21
  8. Pochettino Takes Over at Manchester United Ahead of Liverpool MatchSport · FootballPochettino Takes Over at Manchester United Ahead of Liverpool MatchNov 21
  9. ORCL Stock Week Ahead: Levels and Scenarios for November 23–27Markets · StocksORCL Stock Week Ahead: Levels and Scenarios for November 23–27Nov 21