Cholesterol Study Challenges Three Common Diet Beliefs
A study of about 20,000 women found that the link between saturated fat and heart attacks varied with genetic predisposition to high cholesterol. Its lead researcher cautioned against changing diets based on the findings, which need confirmation in other groups.

Three common cholesterol beliefs face new scrutiny after a study found a genetic difference in how saturated fat intake relates to heart attacks among women. The findings need confirmation before people change their diets, said lead researcher Dr. Shoa Clarke, a cardiologist at Stanford Medicine.
Researchers analyzed data from about 20,000 women whose genes had been sequenced. They grouped the participants by their genetic predisposition to high cholesterol.
Among women with a high predisposition, greater saturated fat intake was associated with more heart attacks. That group accounted for one-quarter of the women studied.
Among the three-quarters with low or medium predisposition, researchers found no correlation between saturated fat intake and heart attacks. The study appeared in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.
Food cholesterol is not a toxin
Cholesterol is a fatty substance that helps build cell membranes and serves as a starting point for making hormones. When people eat too little cholesterol, the liver makes more to compensate.
Cholesterol is also a major component of fatty plaques that build up in arteries. Parts of a plaque can break off and cause blood clots, blocking blood flow to the heart or brain.
Earlier dietary advice focused on avoiding cholesterol-rich foods such as eggs, red meat and shellfish. Doctors now consider that picture misleading.
Low-density lipoprotein, or LDL, carries cholesterol in the blood and is often called bad cholesterol. Doctors believe excess saturated fat encourages the liver to make more LDL, rather than the cholesterol people eat.
Genetics may affect the link
Saturated fat is found mainly in red meat and dairy products, including milk, cream, butter and cheese. Eggs also contain saturated fat, but National Health Service advice says there is no need to limit them.
The study drew on the Women’s Health Initiative, a US study that began in the 1990s. Participants completed dietary surveys, and researchers tracked their health for years.
Clarke cautioned against changing diets on the basis of one study. The findings need to be confirmed in other groups, and the analysis included only women.
Genetic testing of the kind used in the study is not widely available outside research. Clarke also noted other health concerns associated with red meat.
“There are other negative health effects of red meats, even independent of the saturated fat,” Clarke said.
Cholesterol is one part of risk
High cholesterol accounts for one-third of heart disease related to plaque, according to the medical guidelines body Nice.
Plaque inflammation is another concern because it can make a plaque more likely to burst and cause blood clots. Researchers are investigating tests for plaque inflammation and medicines that target it.
Some heart specialists already use a gout medicine off-label for this purpose.
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Lifestyle · Food & HealthNormal Blood Pressure Chart by Age: Healthy Ranges Explained
Lifestyle · Food & HealthWhat Is Raynaud’s Syndrome? Why Fingers Turn White in the Cold
Lifestyle · Food & Health4 Ways Walking After Meals Helps Your Body, Doctors Say
Lifestyle · Food & Health4 Reasons to Eat Oatmeal, According to Nutrition Experts




















