JournalArta
Friday, November 20, 2026 · JakartaS&P 7,175.83 ▼2.02%USD/IDR 18,268 ▲0.06%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Bristol Trial Finds No Clear Advantage in Dialysis Preparation

A UK trial involving 445 older people with kidney failure found no clear advantage to preparing for dialysis over conservative care. Researchers said both options deserve consideration, although the results do not apply to people already receiving dialysis or to younger, fitter patients.

By Alistair Sterling
WIB2 min read
Bristol Trial Finds No Clear Advantage in Dialysis Preparation
Bristol Trial Finds No Clear Advantage in Dialysis Preparation

Researchers at the University of Bristol and Bristol NHS Foundation Trust found no clear advantage to preparing older people with kidney failure for dialysis in a UK trial. The findings could inform treatment decisions for patients elsewhere, project lead Fergus Caskey said.

The trial compared dialysis preparation with conservative kidney care. Neither approach showed a clear advantage when survival and quality of life were assessed together.

Dialysis preparation did not always lead to treatment. Only 28% of participants assigned to that approach went on to start dialysis.

Trial compared two care plans

The Prepare for Kidney Care trial recruited 445 people from 31 kidney centers across the UK. Around three quarters were aged 80 or over.

Advertisement

People aged 65 to 79 could participate if they had frailty or multiple other long-term conditions. Researchers randomly assigned participants to prepare for dialysis or for responsive management, a form of conservative kidney care.

Responsive management focuses on treating symptoms and preserving quality of life as kidney disease progresses. Participants could change their plans, including choosing dialysis after initially starting on the conservative care pathway.

After an average follow-up of 4.5 years, researchers found no statistically significant difference in a measure combining survival and health-related quality of life. The average was 1.35 years in the conservative care group and 1.47 years in the dialysis preparation group.

Advertisement

Hospital admission rates were similar. Participants in both groups were more likely to die from other causes than need dialysis.

Researchers urge shared decisions

The findings are most relevant before dialysis starts, because the trial examined outcomes after patients began planning for either approach. They do not apply to people already receiving dialysis or to younger, fitter patients.

For younger, fitter patients, dialysis and transplantation should remain standard care, the researchers said.

In-hospital hemodialysis can involve three visits a week, each lasting around four hours. Travel and the risk of complications can add to that commitment for people managing other health problems.

Advertisement

Researchers recommend that older patients and their families discuss both options with their kidney teams. Decisions may depend on managing symptoms at home or on the effect of hospital visits on independence and daily routines.

Plans can be revisited if patients’ health or preferences change.

Caskey, professor of renal medicine at Bristol Medical School and a consultant nephrologist at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, said both options have pros and cons. “Neither should be the default,” he said.

Fiona Loud, policy director at Kidney Care UK, said people facing the decision need information, advice and support. “These helpful findings should be studied with care and our NHS should be able to provide that care wherever a person lives,” she said.

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Stock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at MiddayStock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at Midday
  2. 2Joachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 SignalJoachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 Signal
  3. 3Kenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in DoubtKenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in Doubt
  4. 4Pat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell JohnsonPat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell Johnson
  5. 5McDonald’s Workers’ Discrimination Claims Can Go AheadMcDonald’s Workers’ Discrimination Claims Can Go Ahead
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Australians Abandon Job Hunt as Unemployment Hits 4.9%Business · Macro & PolicyAustralians Abandon Job Hunt as Unemployment Hits 4.9%Nov 20
  2. Bondi First Responders Marry Near Scene of AttackWorld · AustraliaBondi First Responders Marry Near Scene of AttackNov 20
  3. Wall Street Open: Target and Babcock Hold Uptrends as Meta, Brent SlideMarkets · StocksWall Street Open: Target and Babcock Hold Uptrends as Meta, Brent SlideNov 20
  4. Ebola Kills 46 Relatives of Congo Man Warning His FamilyLifestyle · Food & HealthEbola Kills 46 Relatives of Congo Man Warning His FamilyNov 20
  5. Advertisement
  6. EPFO Approves Retirement Installments, Raises Withdrawal LimitBusiness · Macro & PolicyEPFO Approves Retirement Installments, Raises Withdrawal LimitNov 20
  7. Alberta Sets New Limits as Canada Expands AI Data CentersTechnology · AIAlberta Sets New Limits as Canada Expands AI Data CentersNov 20
  8. Canada Cross-Border Payment Gateways: CAD and FX FeesMarkets · FintechCanada Cross-Border Payment Gateways: CAD and FX FeesNov 20
  9. Stair Climbing for One Minute May Lower Blood Sugar SpikesLifestyle · Food & HealthStair Climbing for One Minute May Lower Blood Sugar SpikesNov 20