JournalArta
Sunday, November 22, 2026 · JakartaS&P 6,910.39 ▼3.70%USD/IDR 18,260 ▲0.14%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Tesla Merger Scenario Could Give Musk 60% Stake

HSBC analyst Michael Tyndall modeled a SpaceX acquisition of Tesla that would give Elon Musk about 60% of the combined company. His scenario assumes a 33% premium for Tesla shareholders. Independent committees are exploring a deal, but Musk has cautioned that a transaction is far from certain.

By Elena Vance
WIB2 min read
Tesla Merger Scenario Could Give Musk 60% Stake
Tesla Merger Scenario Could Give Musk 60% Stake

Tesla shares fell 6.27% to $350.94 as HSBC analyst Michael Tyndall assessed a possible SpaceX merger that could give Elon Musk about 60% of the combined company. Tyndall’s scenario assumes SpaceX acquires Tesla at a 33% premium to its 30-day average share price.

SpaceX shares fell 6.59% to $129.31. The share prices were recorded during trading on November 20.

Tyndall’s scenario is not an agreed deal. Musk has cautioned that a transaction is far from certain, and both companies have formed committees of independent directors to explore one.

HSBC Models a Tesla Premium

HSBC analyst Michael Tyndall calculated an acquisition value of $507 per Tesla share by applying a 33% premium to the stock’s 30-day average. The calculation assumes SpaceX would acquire the automaker; it does not establish what either company has proposed.

Advertisement

Tyndall said the two businesses serve different customers, limiting the strategic case for combining them. He suggested that their shared need for memory in artificial intelligence and data centers offered a more plausible rationale.

That need may already be addressed by Terafab, the companies’ chip design and manufacturing joint venture, he said.

“We see control as the key motivation for a merger, especially as CEO Musk has been clear in the past about his need for oversight,” Tyndall wrote.

HSBC also estimated that SpaceX shareholders could gain 2.1% to 11.1% in future dilution savings. Dilution reduces existing shareholders’ ownership percentages when a company issues new shares.

Advertisement

Tyndall said both companies consume cash faster than they generate it. If both needed to raise capital to cover shortfalls, Tesla’s lower capital spending requirements could benefit SpaceX, he said.

Musk’s Voting Power and Approval

Musk owns 39% of SpaceX and about 20% of Tesla. His SpaceX stake gives him 70% of the votes because its Class B shares, largely held by Musk, carry 10 votes for each vote attached to Class A shares.

In Tyndall’s acquisition scenario, Musk would hold about 60% of the combined company. The analyst’s calculation assumes SpaceX buys Tesla, rather than the other way around.

On SpaceX’s October 20 third-quarter earnings call, Musk discussed working committees examining a merger but did not give a timeline. On November 18, he said the companies would probably be better together, citing growing overlap in artificial intelligence and robotics.

Musk said a transaction would need approval from owners of at least 50% of all outstanding Tesla shares. He described winning that approval as “quite a high hurdle.”

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Magnitude 4.2 Earthquake Wakes Los Angeles Before DawnMagnitude 4.2 Earthquake Wakes Los Angeles Before Dawn
  2. 2Micron Says Memory Has Changed as Shares Fall 13.89%Micron Says Memory Has Changed as Shares Fall 13.89%
  3. 3Dow Jones Futures Await Reopening After Tech Stocks SlideDow Jones Futures Await Reopening After Tech Stocks Slide
  4. 4US Shoppers Reject Cheap Fabrics as Clothing Prices RiseUS Shoppers Reject Cheap Fabrics as Clothing Prices Rise
  5. 5ORCL Stock Week Ahead: Levels and Scenarios for November 23–27ORCL Stock Week Ahead: Levels and Scenarios for November 23–27
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Paula Patton, Derek Luke Reunite in Love on the VineyardLifestyle · EntertainmentPaula Patton, Derek Luke Reunite in Love on the VineyardNov 22
  2. Australia’s Economy Faces Rising Recession Risk as Joblessness Hits 4.9%Business · Macro & PolicyAustralia’s Economy Faces Rising Recession Risk as Joblessness Hits 4.9%Nov 22
  3. TCU Faces No. 2 Utah and Nation’s Longest Winning StreakSport · FootballTCU Faces No. 2 Utah and Nation’s Longest Winning StreakNov 22
  4. Indonesia Motorcycle Exports Reach 81 CountriesIndonesia · NewsIndonesia Motorcycle Exports Reach 81 CountriesNov 22
  5. Advertisement
  6. Kukoc: Rodman Exercised After Bulls Won by 30 PointsSport · BasketballKukoc: Rodman Exercised After Bulls Won by 30 PointsNov 22
  7. Blue Jackets vs. Maple Leafs: Lorentz Criticizes Trade HandlingSport · More SportsBlue Jackets vs. Maple Leafs: Lorentz Criticizes Trade HandlingNov 22
  8. Islanders vs. Red Wings: Cizikas Set for 1,000th GameSport · More SportsIslanders vs. Red Wings: Cizikas Set for 1,000th GameNov 22
  9. Fox Sports Rests Khawaja, Warner for England T20 SeriesSport · More SportsFox Sports Rests Khawaja, Warner for England T20 SeriesNov 22